Correct. The Frame tube is bent in....His picture is worth a thousand word's!Herb wrote: ↑Tue Oct 10, 2023 6:53 pmSince I cannot inspect the bike in person I am not sure of the real problem. Although from my experience of almost doing the same thing, I can say that it is most likely that the foot peg bracket on the left side is twisted down. If the frame were bent it would be bent in, not out, because the weight of the bike would have pushed the frame in not pulled it out.Designer wrote: ↑Tue Oct 10, 2023 1:47 pmYes,....doing so will allow the Footrest to be attached. However, this will not fix the problem,....that being,..... the Left Side Frame Tube is bent inwards.
This will just move the mis-alignment issues to other nearby spots on the bike, so to speak. Firstly,...the Front Engine Mounting point on the Frame will get bent and/or cracked. Also,. the lateral forces induced on the Foot Rest Bolts ( called Shear) is not a desirable thing. It is the Bolt's weakest Stressing Manner..( those being Tension, Compression, Shear) .
Personally I'd perform a Method to re-align the Left Side Frame Tube outwards to it's original position,....it's not all that difficult, ....and would return things to sound and good order once again.
Footrest won't reattach to frame
- Designer
- Joined a 1200cc Club
- Posts: 17509
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2014 8:34 am
- My Bike: Two 1400 Custom Made Choppers
Re: Footrest won't reattach to frame
- hillsy v2
- Bike out of hock
- Posts: 3144
- Joined: Wed Jul 27, 2022 5:35 pm
- My Bike: Too many to list
Re: Footrest won't reattach to frame
Fer fks sake - just loosen the frame rail and get all the bolts back in. Tighten them up a bit at a time and it will straighten up. Lever the frame rail over if you have to.
Not rocket science.
Not rocket science.
- Designer
- Joined a 1200cc Club
- Posts: 17509
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2014 8:34 am
- My Bike: Two 1400 Custom Made Choppers
Re: Footrest won't reattach to frame
I won't go into the "loosening the frame" method and the ramifications of doing it again,.......all that has been covered well enough already.
This suggestion of levering the frame over is pretty risky as there is a distinct possibility of doing damage to the Engine Cases.
Firstly, there is no way of knowing beforehand just how much Levering Force will be needed to move it back to original position. And the spaces are tight around the Engine-to-Frame in this area,.....thus probably might not allow for a sufficient Lever "push point/pad" on the Engine Case to move the frame over. A Pry Bar would needs to be having a rather small Engine Case Contact area, thus might damage the Engine......Why risk that?
There is a much safer way.
This suggestion of levering the frame over is pretty risky as there is a distinct possibility of doing damage to the Engine Cases.
Firstly, there is no way of knowing beforehand just how much Levering Force will be needed to move it back to original position. And the spaces are tight around the Engine-to-Frame in this area,.....thus probably might not allow for a sufficient Lever "push point/pad" on the Engine Case to move the frame over. A Pry Bar would needs to be having a rather small Engine Case Contact area, thus might damage the Engine......Why risk that?
There is a much safer way.
-
- Joined a 1100cc Club
- Posts: 5511
- Joined: Thu Dec 29, 2016 12:33 pm
- My Bike: VS800
Re: Footrest won't reattach to frame
Designer...what exactly is your "much safer way"?
Pull the engine and throw the frame on a frame straightening jig?
I stand by what I said. Good Luck Hadrian.
Pull the engine and throw the frame on a frame straightening jig?
I stand by what I said. Good Luck Hadrian.
- hillsy v2
- Bike out of hock
- Posts: 3144
- Joined: Wed Jul 27, 2022 5:35 pm
- My Bike: Too many to list
Re: Footrest won't reattach to frame
If you're not going to pry it all back to line it up then that's probably the only other option.
Again - not rocket science.....unless you want to make it more complicated than it needs to be.
- Designer
- Joined a 1200cc Club
- Posts: 17509
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2014 8:34 am
- My Bike: Two 1400 Custom Made Choppers
Re: Footrest won't reattach to frame
So sorry guys,....but,.....Nope.
There is another way that is far less work.
There is another way that is far less work.
-
- Joined a 1100cc Club
- Posts: 5511
- Joined: Thu Dec 29, 2016 12:33 pm
- My Bike: VS800
- Herb
- Joined a 1200cc Club
- Posts: 19371
- Joined: Sun Oct 26, 2014 9:28 pm
- My Bike: 1999 1400 intruder
Re: Footrest won't reattach to frame
If it is so good and easy why didn't you post that method in the first place? What is it?
I can't seem to win the lottery. I think I have used up all of my good luck riding motorcycles.
- Herb
- Joined a 1200cc Club
- Posts: 19371
- Joined: Sun Oct 26, 2014 9:28 pm
- My Bike: 1999 1400 intruder
Re: Footrest won't reattach to frame
meanwhile, the OP has given up on posting and we don't know if he ever got it fixed.
I can't seem to win the lottery. I think I have used up all of my good luck riding motorcycles.
- Designer
- Joined a 1200cc Club
- Posts: 17509
- Joined: Tue Sep 16, 2014 8:34 am
- My Bike: Two 1400 Custom Made Choppers
Re: Footrest won't reattach to frame
After looking at the Picture of the Bent Frame/Engine in more detail and thinking about the forces needed, I surmised what I said about the levering idea mentioned here.
viewtopic.php?f=13&t=14712&start=42
So I thought to myself,..."Self,...what about using gravity instead?"
Since the Frame was bent by the weight of the bike in the first place, why not use that same amount/type of force in reverse?
To do so,...one would first need to remove the Right Side Header to create the space needed to bend the Frame past Original Position ( Why is because bending Steel would rebound a little bit). Then, one would bolt the Foot Rest to the Left Side Frame only ( using some Grade 8 Bolts because of Shear forces). Then, one would place on the Ground a Wood "support" on the Right Side ( to mimic the Kickstand that supported the Left Side of the bike when the Frame got bent in the first place). Then one would tip the Bike over onto the Wood support. Using the bolted-on Foot Rest as a measuring "yardstick" to view the progress, one could monitor the movement of the Left Side frame so as to keep from overdoing it. When one sees the Right Side Footrest-to-Frame Bolt Holes align as they did originally, one then knows all is pretty much as it should be. Then one would Bolt everything back up...and...VOILA....one has fixed it!
viewtopic.php?f=13&t=14712&start=42
So I thought to myself,..."Self,...what about using gravity instead?"
Since the Frame was bent by the weight of the bike in the first place, why not use that same amount/type of force in reverse?
To do so,...one would first need to remove the Right Side Header to create the space needed to bend the Frame past Original Position ( Why is because bending Steel would rebound a little bit). Then, one would bolt the Foot Rest to the Left Side Frame only ( using some Grade 8 Bolts because of Shear forces). Then, one would place on the Ground a Wood "support" on the Right Side ( to mimic the Kickstand that supported the Left Side of the bike when the Frame got bent in the first place). Then one would tip the Bike over onto the Wood support. Using the bolted-on Foot Rest as a measuring "yardstick" to view the progress, one could monitor the movement of the Left Side frame so as to keep from overdoing it. When one sees the Right Side Footrest-to-Frame Bolt Holes align as they did originally, one then knows all is pretty much as it should be. Then one would Bolt everything back up...and...VOILA....one has fixed it!